In Our Toaster: Second Bite on Columbus Ave

🥪 The Sequel Sandwich Spot: Lenwich at 302 Columbus

There’s just something about the Upper West Side—brownstones, bookstores, and the perfect sandwich shop on every block (or at least, we try). Sitting pretty on 74th Street, Lenwich at 302 Columbus Ave is our second-born baby—and it’s still bringing the flavor.

🔁 Second Bite, Same Obsession

This was the second Lenwich ever opened, right after our OG spot on 84th. Back then, we were Lenny’s Gourmet. Today, it’s still the same sandwich soul, just with more bread options and better napkins. 

👋 Why Locals Love It

Speed, smiles, and sandwiches you actually crave. Our crew keeps it moving but never forgets a face (or your “light mayo” request). Regulars know this one’s a hidden gem.

🔥 What to Order

• Chickavo – Grilled chicken, avocado, and all the good stuff.

• Tuna Pesto – Classic tuna meets bold basil energy.

• Buffalo Chicken Wrap – Tangy, crunchy, perfect every time.
  
  

🗺️ In the Neighborhood

Swing by post-park, pre-museum, or mid-stroll. We're a quick bite from Central Park, the Museum of Natural History, and all the charm of the UWS. Whether you’re reliving your sandwich roots or just passing through, 302 Columbus is where history gets toasted.